skip to content

Von Hügel Institute

for Critical Catholic Inquiry

The group led by Dr Flavio Comim will read and discuss The Cosmopolitan Tradition: A Noble but Flawed Ideal by Martha Nussbaum (Harward University Press, 2019).

WHEN: Wednesdays, 5-7 pm, starting on Wednesday 12 February until 4 March

WHERE: Meeting Room, Benet House, St Edmund’s College

HOW IT WORKS: participants present different chapters followed by discussions. During the first session Dr Comim will give an introduction to the volume and all chapters will be assigned for presentation.

For registration and further information please contact Dr Flavio Comim All are welcome. Coffee and tea served.

Nussbaum cosmopolitan tradition - cover

About the book

The cosmopolitan political tradition in Western thought begins with the Greek Cynic Diogenes, who, when asked where he came from, responded that he was a citizen of the world. Rather than declaring his lineage, city, social class, or gender, he defined himself as a human being, implicitly asserting the equal worth of all human beings. Martha Nussbaum pursues this “noble but flawed” vision of world citizenship as it finds expression in figures of Greco-Roman antiquity, Hugo Grotius in the seventeenth century, Adam Smith during the eighteenth century, and various contemporary thinkers. She confronts its inherent tensions: the ideal suggests that moral personality is complete, and completely beautiful, without any external aids, while reality insists that basic material needs must be met if people are to realize fully their inherent dignity. Given the global prevalence of material want, the lesser social opportunities of people with physical and cognitive disabilities, the conflicting beliefs of a pluralistic society, and the challenge of mass migration and asylum seekers, what political principles should we endorse? Nussbaum brings her version of the Capabilities Approach to these problems, and she goes further: she takes on the challenge of recognizing the moral claims of nonhuman animals and the natural world.

The insight that politics ought to treat human beings both as equal to each other and as having a worth beyond price is responsible for much that is fine in the modern Western political imagination. The Cosmopolitan Tradition extends Nussbaum’s work, urging us to focus on the humanity we share rather than all that divides us.

Wednesday, 12 February, 2020 - 17:00 to Wednesday, 4 March, 2020 - 19:00
Event location: 
Meeting Room, Benet House, St Edmund's College CB3 0BN



A unique institute of advanced studies inspired by Catholic thought and culture, focussed on contemporary global realities, and dedicated to encounter, dialogue, and transformation